Introduction
The fresh avocado has acquired in recent years' great importance in international consumption. Mexico is the world's leading avocado exporter and represents around 45% of world exports. The second place is occupied by Peru with 179 thousand tons corresponding to 12.7% of the total. Exports in 2017 totaled 558 million dollars (Koo, 2017), consolidating Peru as one of the main suppliers of avocados to the United States and the European Union (MINAGRI, 2015).
Production as the export of avocados is on the rise and brings with it a progressive increase in the volumes of discard type fruit, which is sold in the national markets at lower prices. The industrialization of these remnants becomes an increasingly important alternative for its use. The avocado is raw material rich in oil, so the extraction and production of it can be considered as an interesting option. Avocado oil extracted from ripe fruits has a high oleic acid content, which constitutes a safe and healthy food, in addition to containing vitamin E (α tocopherol), 10.11 mg/100 g, which behaves as a protective agent against oxidation, increasing the shelf life of the product (Nwaokobia et al., 2018, Betancur et al., 2017). The evaluation of the shelf life of vegetable oils is important in the food industry because it ensures the quality and safety with which the product will be distributed. Tests of accelerated storage by static and dynamic methods allow estimating the shelf life of oils. Static methods such as peroxide index allow periodic detection of product oxidation due to oxidation, and dynamic methods such as RANCIMAT measure oxidation induction time, and it is more reliable, reproducible and time-consuming (Aktar and Adal, 2019).
Landeo (2019) used the static method to estimate the shelf life of aguaje (Mauritia flexuosa) oil. The oil was extracted by the press and stored in amber bottles for five days at 45 °C, 55 °C and 65 °C.
The peroxide index was evaluated during the storage days. The Arrhenius mathematical model was used to determine the rate of deterioration of the oil concerning for to temperature, extrapolation was performed at 18 °C. This resulted in 272 days of product shelf life (Iparraguirre, 2019).
Iparraguirre (2019) evaluated the shelf life of sacha inchi oil by the dynamic method. The oil was extracted by cold pressing and subjected to RANCIMAT at 70 °C, 80° C, 90 °C and 100 °C. The results showed that the shelf life of sacha inchi oil was 0.12 years. Another similar study was carried out by Aktar and Adal (2019). Avocado oil was extracted by centrifugation and subjected to RANCIMAT at temperatures of 100 °C, 110 °C, 120 °C, 130 °C and 140 °C. The results showed that the shelf life of avocado oil was 210 days. The scientific literature presents little information on studies carried out in determining the shelf life of avocado oil, for this reason, the present study was carried out, whose objective was to obtain and physicochemical characterize the Hass avocado oil type discarded by the cold and hot method, to obtain a product with optimal quality conditions and with beneficial components of the Health.
Materials and methods
In the present investigation, samples of avocado Hass type discarded were donated by the municipality of Cascajal, Ancash-Peru.
Extraction of Hass Avocado Oil
The Hass avocado pulp discarded by low-caliber was subjected to the extraction of oil by the cold and hot method as shown in Figure 1, respectively.
Physicochemical Characteristics
The chemical characteristics evaluated were: Peroxide index (PI) according to the AOCS method Cd 8-53, Acidity index (AI) according to the method of ISO 660: 2009; Iodine index (II) using the Wijs method, following AOAC 993.20 (1995). The physical characteristics evaluated were: Relative Density (RD) using the pycnometer method according to the CODEX, Refraction index (RI) was carried out following the method AOCS-Cc 7-25 (1998). The Rudolph Research brand digital refractometer (Model J157) was used, Melting Point (MP) was carried out following the closed capillary method, regulated by INEN 0474: 1980, and Instrumental Color by the CIELAB method, using a digital colorimeter KONICA MINOLTA (CR-400T). The fatty acids composition was determined according to the Fames method, AOAC 991.39 (2003).
Oxidative stability and shelf life of avocado oil
The determination of the shelf life was carried out using the extrapolation method at the usual storage temperature (25 °C). Each analysis was performed in triplicate, using the equipment Rancimat, Metrohm 743 brand, where 3g of the sample was subjected to temperatures of 140, 160 and 180 °C for both types of oils, at a constant airflow of 20 L/h (Nakatane et al., 2001).
Statics Analyses
The analyses were performed in triplicate, and the results were treated statistically by calculating means and standard deviations. Analysis of variance (ANOVA) and Tuckey test were performed to compare means in both oils and determine if there are significant differences between the results for each analysis (RD, RI, AI, II, PI, MP and instrumental color) for this the Stat Graphics Centurion software (version 2014, USA) was used. The differences were considered statistically significant at a level of p < 0.05.
Results and discussion
Table 1 shows the results of the physical and chemical characteristics of oils obtained by the cold method (CMO) and by the hot method (HMO), respectively. Except for color, characteristics such as RD, RI, MP, AI, PI and II showed statistically significant differences in both treatments.
Determination of relative density (RD)
The value obtained from the HMO, 0.81 (20 °C / water at 20 °C), was lower compared to virgin olive oil (0.91 - 0.92) (Codex Stan 210:1999) while that of the CMO, 0.95 (20 °C / water at 20 °C), was higher. The value obtained from the CMO was lower compared to virgin olive oil (0.91-0.92) (Codex Stan 210:1999) while that of the HMO was higher. Also, the Mexican technical standard, NMX-F-052-SCFI: 2008, indicates values for avocado oil between 0.91 and 0.92, so both oils are outside the limits established by this technical standard. According to Lewis (1993), density is a parameter that is directly related to molecular weight, and indirect to the degree of unsaturation of the sample. As the CMO presents greater density, it can be inferred that it presents a higher degree of unsaturation than the HMO. This low HMO unsaturation can be due to the thermal degradation suffered by unsatura-ted fatty acids when exposed to high extraction temperatures (Reda, 2011).
Refraction index (RI)
Concerning RI, HMO has a lower value compared to other oils of similar composition, such as olive oil (1.46 - 1.47 at 20 °C) (Codex Stan 210:1999). Similar data were reported in Hass avocado oil obtained using petroleum ether as a solvent by Guzman et al. (2008) and González (2009), these refraction indexes were 1.47 and 1.48, respectively. For oils extracted in cold, the Mexican technical standard, NMX-F-052-SCFI: 2008, indicates RI values between 1.45 - 1.46 (40 °C) and Guzman et al. (2008) RI values of 1.47 (25 °C). The latter was similar to the one obtained in the CMO. The RI values in an oil sample are related to the degree of unsaturation and the Cis/Trans ratio of the double bonds (Gutierrez et al., 2011). Its value can be altered by the oxidation of fatty acids (Hamilton and Rossel, 1987), so it can be inferred that the HMO, having a higher RI value than the CMO, was influenced by the extraction method and that during its measurement the oil had some oxidation of fatty acids.
Determination of the Melting point (MP)
The value obtained from HMO, 15 °C, is high compared to virgin olive oil (5 °C - 12 °C) (Codex Stan, 210:1999) while the CMO, 12 °C, shows a value within the range. According to Nwaokobia et al. (2018), the melting points of fatty acids present in an oil increase with the length of the chain and decrease with an increase in the establishment. The presence of impurities in the oil also alters the MP, so this constant constitutes a good criterion of purity.
Unsaturated fatty acids generally have lower melting points than saturated fatty. Therefore, it is inferred that CMO retains a greater amount of unsaturated fatty acids than HMO.
Color determination
In HMO, a* value, being negative and found between the values of 0 and -10, shows a tendency to dark green. The value presented by b* shows a tendency to yellow. Both trends to the green and yellow color are typical of avocado oil which makes it very attractive to the eye of the consumer. Reed (2001) concluded that avocado oil, unlike olive oil, has higher levels of chlorophyll, so the oil will always show a tendency to green. As for the chroma, the HMO presented a greater value (46.29) compared to the one obtained in CMO (39.83), although both belong to the second quadrant between the green and yellow tones, the latter has a greener shade than the other.
* Results presented and average values ± SD. L: Brightness; a: red/green; b: blue/yellow; C*: Chroma; h°: hue angle. Different letters indicate a significant statistical difference between the means of the treatments according to the Tukey test at a significance level of 0.05.
According to Muños-López et al. (2018) chroma may increase during the lyophilization process of the plant material and consequently in the final product. This indicates the concentration of chlorophyll and other pigments contained in the avocado, compared with samples dried with collective heat. Concerning for to the brightness values and chroma in CMO, they showed values of less than 48.72 and 39.82, respectively. The mean value of a* was -9.92, which shows a tendency to the green color and the value of b* to the yellow color resulting similar to the oil obtained by the hot method. The hue angle (h°) was greater (104.43), which corresponds to a green color than that obtained by the hot method. According to Badui (2006), the color of the food is due to different compounds, mainly organic or natural pigments that when subjected to thermal treatments generate shades ranging from a light yellow to an intense coffee, through the Maillard reaction (Braverman, 1988; Yaylayan, 1990) and caramelization, on other occasions, the pigments they contain change and change color.
Acidity index (AI)
The acidity results of the CMO (0.91 ± 0.09 oleic acid mg KOH / g oil) are similar to those reported by the CODEX STAN 210: 1999, for olive oil (0.3 - 0.6 oleic acid mg KOH / g oil) while the HMO shows a value outside the range. For the Mexican technical standard, NMX-F-052-SCFI: 2008, the acidity obtained by both oils is within the established range (0.1 - 1.5 oleic acid mg KOH / g oil) as well as the Brazilian legislation that allows a maximum acid value of 4.0 mg KOH / g for any type of vegetable oil obtained by pressing (ANVISA, 2005). Peruvian legislation does not have any specific regulations for avocado oil. The comparison of the AI between both samples of oils, the HMO presented greater value than the CMO that can be due to the alteration in the concentration of hydrogen ions, due to an initial process of decomposition (Instituto Adolfo Lutz, 2008) as the hydrolytic rancidity that causes the release of fatty acids (Badui, 2006).
Iodine index (II)
For II, the result obtained from the HMO was similar to that obtained by Restrepo et al. (2002) that reported values of 77.85 cg I2 / g oil using hexane as solvent. Also, the value obtained is within the maximum limit established by the Mexican Technical Standard, NMX-F-052-SCFI: 2008, 80-90 g I2 / g oil. The higher the iodine index, the lower the presence of saturated fatty acids (Calabrese, 1992) since it is a measure of the state of non-saturation of lipids. According to the above, the CMO preserves the greater amount of unsaturated fatty acids as opposed to HMO as well as a greater predisposetion to present oxidative reactions that deteriorate the oil (Jimenez et al., 2011).
Peroxide index (PI)
Concerning for to the PI, both oils obtained a value within the range established by CODEX STAN 210: 1999, for virgin olive oil (≤ 20 meq de O2/kg). However, according to the Mexican Technical Standard, NMX-F-052-SCFI: 2008, avocado oil should have a maximum value of 10 meq de O2/kg compared to the values obtained, these were relatively higher (CMO: 10.45 and HMO: 19.18 meq de O2/kg). The PI values close to 10 presented by both oil samples may be due to the high degree of unsaturation that avocado oil presents, which influence the speed of oxidation since the unsaturated fatty acids when they are free are oxidized in general faster than saturated fatty acids (Velasco et al., 2004).
Saturated fatty acids are only oxidized at temperatures above 60 °C, while polyunsa-turated acids are oxidized even during the storage of frozen food (Martinez, 2008).
Fatty acids composition
Table 2 shows the results of the fatty acid composition of oils obtained by the cold method (CMO) and by the hot method (HMO), respectively.
The HMO consists mostly of saturated fatty acids, while the CMO consists mostly of unsaturated fatty acids. In the case of HMO, oleic acid (18: 1 w9) represents more than 35% of the totality while the arachidonic acid (20: 4 w6) reaches 20%. The CMO is made up mostly of oleic acid, more than 40%, while the arachidonic acid is less than 20%. Saturated fatty acids are present in both oils in a very similar proportion to that of unsaturated fatty acids.
Type of Fatty Acids | Fatty Acid | Unit | Concentration (HMO) | Concentration (CMO) |
Saturated | Palmitic Acid | % (g/100 g) | 28.4 | 26.45 |
Heptadecanoic Acid | % (g/100 g) | 14.43 | 13.58 | |
Unsaturated | Oleic Acid | % (g/100 g) | 39.73 | 42.99 |
Poly Unsaturated | Arachidonic Acid | % (g/100 g) | 17.12 | 16.99 |
Olaeta et al. (1999) report that oleic acid varies between 48.4 and 66.8% for avocado oil Hass variety, this value is close to that obtained by Human (1987), which indicates that the relative percentage of oleic acid in avocado Hass, is around 70.5%. The concentration of oleic acid obtained in the present investigation was 39.73%. These obtained concentrations can be attributed to the state of development of the fruit, which influences the variation of the lipid content (Pérez et al., 2005).
The second most important acid is arachidonic acid. The CMO presents high levels of polyunsaturated fatty acids (16.99%) unlike olive oil (10.66%), but lower than sunflower oil (61.39%) (Blanco et al., 2006).
The arachidonic acid has twenty carbons in its structure and belongs to the family of ω-6; according to Valenzuela et al. (2011) these compounds play critical roles in the structure of cell membranes and the immune system of the human body, so they are essential for the body and should be included in the diet.
There was no presence of linolenic acid in the avocado oils obtained (Table 2); according to Mataix and Gil (2002), the avocado oil contains a low amount of this unsaturated acid.
Shelf Life of avocado oil
Table 3 shows the shelf life of avocado oil (HMO and CMO) estimated at 25 °C by extrapolation (Figures 2a and 2b), as well as the comparison with other vegetable oils.
The shelf life of CMO was relatively shorter, compared to the HMO, due to the high degree of chemical reactivity presented by its unsaturation. When comparing the results with those obtained in other vegetable oils (Table 3), it can be observed that the avocado oil had a longer shelf life than the sacha inchi, Mauritia flexuosa oil and cottonseed oils. This difference can be attributed to the higher percentage of polyunsaturated acids present in cottonseed and sacha inchi oils, which are 41.6% (Alemayhu et al., 2019) and 33.9% (Castaño et al., 2012), respectively, while the avocado oil (CMO) extracted in the present study obtained approximately 17%. According to Landeo (2019), polyunsaturated fatty acids are less stable than monounsaturated acids due to the presence of more than two unsaturation, which makes oxygen easily absorbed by the oils.
Sample | Shelf life (years) | Method | References |
HMO oil | 5.94 | Rancimat | This research |
CMO oil | 4.41 | Rancimat | This research |
Olive oil | 1.85 | Rancimat | Farhoosh et al. (2013) |
Peanut oil | 0.87 | Peroxide analysis | Alemayhu et al. (2019) |
Cottonseed oil | 0.78 | Peroxide analysis | Alemayhu et al. (2019) |
Mauritia flexuosa oil | 0.74 | Peroxide analysis | Landeo (2019) |
Sacha Inchi oil | 0.25 | Peroxide analysis | Iparraguirre (2019) |
Olive oil and peanut oil have lower polyunsaturated content but higher monounsaturated content than sacha inchi oil and cottonseed oil, 56.82% and 46.2%, respectively (Alemayhu et al., 2019). The avocado oil obtained in the present study showed 42.9% of unsaturated fatty acids and 40.3% of saturated fatty acids, presenting greater stability than the vegetable oils mentioned above and therefore a longer shelf life.
According to Zambrano-Herrera et al. (2017), the PI in an oil sample decreases the shelf life of the oil. However, the values obtained from IP and shelf life do not show a direct relationship. This, probably at Ranci-mat oxidation that generates an immediate appearance of primary and secondary compounds that cannot be fully detected by a peroxide analysis (Rodriguez et al., 2015).
The shelf life of an oil decreases during storage due to the degradation of its compounds that can be due to factors such as light, temperature, presence of oxygen and the high amount of unsaturated fatty acids. Oxidations are mainly carried out in these fatty acids than in saturated oils that are oxidized from 60 °C and polyunsaturated oils that are oxidized even when frozen (Pereyra et al., 2009).
Conclusions
Four fatty acids were found for both HMO and CMO; however, the CMO showed a lower percentage of saturated fatty acids and a higher percentage of unsaturated fatty acids, especially oleic acid, than the HMO. The convenient ingestion of this unsaturated fatty acid provides healthy characteristics for the human being.
The Shelf life, measured as a function of the oxidative rancidity, of the CMO was 4 years while that of the HMO was 5 years, inferring a high antioxidant capacity and high stability. The physicochemical characteristics of the CMO as acidity index, melting point and refractive index are within the acceptable ranges according to the international food standards for vegetable oils and the Mexican technical standards for avocado oil. In the HMO, only the acidity index is within these ranges.