SciELO - Scientific Electronic Library Online

 
vol.21 issue2Platelet / spleen ratio for the diagnosis of esophageal varices and the risk of bleeding in patients with liver failureApplication of panoramic t2 sequence for magnetic resonance imaging of lumbosacral spine author indexsubject indexarticles search
Home Pagealphabetic serial listing  

Services on Demand

Journal

Article

Indicators

  • Have no cited articlesCited by SciELO

Related links

  • Have no similar articlesSimilars in SciELO

Share


Revista de la Facultad de Medicina Humana

Print version ISSN 1814-5469On-line version ISSN 2308-0531

Rev. Fac. Med. Hum. vol.21 no.2 Lima Apr-Jun 2021

http://dx.doi.org/10.25176/rfmh.v21i2.3715 

Original article

Employees’ perception of management skills at Hospital Municipal Los Olivos

Irma Emperatriz Arrascue-Lino1  , Nursing graduate

Luis E. Podestá-Gavilano2  , MD. General Surgery

Juan P. Matzumura-Kasano3  , PhD in medicine

Hugo F. Gutiérrez-Crespo3  , Master in Health Teaching and Research

Raúl A. Ruiz-Arias4  , Master in Statistics

1Superintendencia Nacional de Salud. Lima, Perú.

2Hospital II Vitarte Essalud. Lima, Perú

3Universidad Nacional Mayor de San Marcos. Lima, Perú.

4Universidad Nacional Federico Villarreal. Lima, Perú.

ABSTRACT

Objective:

: Analyze management skills from employees’ perception in the Los Olivos Municipal Hospital in 2019.

Methods:

Quantitative, correlational, cross-sectional study. A simple random sample of 52 participants was applied. We used a questionnaire to assess perceptions regarding management skills, consisting of 27 questions and 4 dimensions, with a Cronbach’s alpha reliability value of 0.97. We used Pearson’s chi-squared test to analyze correlation between management skills variable and sociodemographic variables.

Results:

Management skills were considered adequate in analytic and interpersonal dimensions by 69% of participants, while emotional and motivational skills and values were considered regular by 69% and 58%, respectively. 55.8% of participants perceived their bosses’ management skills as adequate, 44.2% perceived them as regular, and none as inadequate. The only sociodemographic variable that was associated with management skills was service time.

Conclusion:

55.8% of the health personnel in the Los Olivos Municipal Hospital perceived management skills as adequate.

Key words: Governance; Health Services Administration; and Hospital Administration. (Source: MeSH NLM)

INTRODUCTION

21st century organizations require trained managers who have skills to allow them to implement processes for decision-making with guarantees of permanent adaptation to confront different situations. In an extremely changing and competitive environment, human resources are the element which makes the competitive difference between companies1.

In some health establishments, there is an absence of directors with managerial capacity and strategic thinking, this influences their functioning without adequate execution of administrative processes, which is reflected in their various organizational levels2. Management skills consist of identifiable actions performed by individuals in order to lead to certain results3. These skills, at present, have acquired greater importance and are the engine of transformation of organizations, for this reason there is a tendency to select personnel who have these skills, since their quality and profitability depend on it4.

Managers, therefore, must combine leadership, entrepreneurship and skills to meet the challenges of the changing socio-political, economic and technological scenery, as well as meet the expectations of patients and healthcare professionals. Without proper management, it is not possible to improve the efficiency, effectiveness, and response capacity in the provision of health services5.

The hospital, specifically, is an organization which includes human talent, financial and technological resources, those elements work in coordination to deliver a service for society. This is why health organizations need competent managers on charge, who plan, organize, direct and control hospital processes. In this sense, it is not enough for the manager to possess technical knowledge and higher education, but also the ability to handle various skills in the exercise of their functions, with a high level of efficiency6.

In Peru, public management professionals are scarce, either because salaries are not attractive for high-level professionals or because there is not adequate preparation to assume this kind of positions.7. Therefore, in addition to providing new study material, the present research aims to analyze management skills from the employees’ perception at Hospital Municipal Los Olivos during 2019.

METHODS

Correlational cross-sectional study. The population was made up of 249 participants from the Hospital Municipal Los Olivos, including health care personnel (nursing degree, obstetrician, nutritionist, pharmaceutical chemist, medical technologist, nursing technician, laboratory technician and pharmacy technician) and administrative personnel (civil servant and administrative technician). A simple probabilistic sample made up of 52 participants was applied. Service independent personnel were excluded. The variables studied were managerial skills and sociodemographic variables (sex, age, work condition, time of service and occupation). To measure management skills, the questionnaire designed by Moreno-Galarreta was used, adapted to be applied to health personnel and not to bosses or managers. It has a reliability of 0.97 according to Cronbach's alpha8. It is made up of 27 questions and four dimensions: motivations and values, analytical skills, interpersonal skills, and emotional skills. The answers are determined by means of alternatives on the Likert scale, with the numerical evaluation, respectively, of each one (1 to 5). The assessment scale is determined as inadequate (27-63 points), regular (64-99 points) and adequate (100-135 points).

The data were processed using R software, a free-use statistical program. The information was arranged in frequencies tables which were adapted to the variables and dimensions analyzed. Descriptive statistics were used, focusing on measures of central tendency and measures of dispersion. For the analysis of the relationship between the managerial skills variable with the sociodemographic variables, Pearson's Chi-square statistical test was applied. The study was approved and authorized by the general director of the Hospital Los Olivos Municipal. The ethical norms of the Helsinki Declaration for the rights protection of the personnel who participated in the research were taken into account.

RESULTS

From the review of the processed data, we found the participants average age is 37.3 ± 8.8 years; 84.6% of the participants are female, with a predominance of the age group between 26 and 37 years (57.7%). 88.5% had an administrative service contract as a work condition. 75% work in the hospital for less than five years. 59.6% of the participants correspond to nursing personnel (Table 1). The study sample consisted of 52 participants who met the inclusion criteria.

Table 1.  Correlation analysis between managerial skills variable and sociodemographic variables in the staff at Hospital Municipal Los Olivos. Lima 2019. 

Sociodemographic variables Total Management skills p value
Regular (n=23) Adequate (n=29)
n % n % n %
Gender            
  Female 44 84,6 20 45,5 24 54,5
  Male 8 15,4 3 37,5 5 62,5 0,677
Age (Years)
  26 to 37 30 57,7 13 43,3 17 56,7 0,601
  38 to 47 16 30,8 6 37,5 10 62,5
  48 to 57 4 7,7 3 75 1 25
  58 to 67 2 3,8 1 50 1 50
Working condition
  Administrative service contract 46 88,5 21 45,7 25 54,3 0,432
  Indeterminate contract 6 7,7 2 33,3 4 66,7
Service time (years)      
  Until 5 39 75,0 13 33,3 26 66,7 0,021
  6 to 10 7 13,5 5 71,4 2 28,6
  11 to 15 6 11,5 5 83,3 1 16,7
Occupation
  Nursing technician 18 34,6 11 61,1 7 38,9 0,295
  Degree in nursing 13 25 4 30,8 9 69,2
  Administrative technician 5 9,6 1 20 4 80
  Obstetrician 3 5,8 1 33,3 2 66,7
  Medical Technologist 3 5,8 2 66,7 1 33,3
  Official 2 3,8 0 0,0 2 100,0
  Nutritionist 2 3,8 1 50 1 50,0
  Pharmaceutical chemist 2 3,8 0 0,0 2 100
  Pharmacy Technician 2 3,8 1 50 1 50
  Laboratory technician 2 3,8 2 100,0 0 0,0

The responses analysis of the motivations and values dimension, allowed to identify 59.6% perceived that they always maintain the desire to achieve achievements in their work and 36.5% almost always maintain their desire to inspect and supervise the activities of their subordinates, as well as the desire for a high level of responsibility.

In analytical skills dimension, 34.6% always find and implement different solutions for different problems and 46.2% almost always evaluate information that has not been collected by the same person (Table 2).

Table 2.  Scale of evaluations on managerial skills in their motivations and values and analytical dimensions according to the perception of the Los Olivos Municipal Hospital staff. Lima 2019. 

Dimensions / indicators Rating scale
Never Rarely Some times Usually Always
n (%) n (%) n (%) n (%) n (%)
Motivations and values          
Desire to achieve accomplishment in their job. 2 3,8 0 0,0 6 11,5 13 25 31 59,6
Desire to function as a boss / manager, free from functional or technical concerns. 5 9,6 11 21,2 24 46.2 9 17,3 3 5,8
Desire for a high level of responsibility. 0 0,0 1 1,9 14 26,9 19 36,5 18 34,6
Willingness to take risks when making difficult decisions. 1 1,9 4 7,7 18 34,6 16 30,8 16 25
Desire to inspect and supervise the activities of their subordinates. 3 5,8 8 15,4 10 19,2 19 36,5 12 23,1
Analytical skills
Identify problems in complex and ambiguous situation. 0 0,0 5 9,6 15 28,8 23 44,2 9 17,3
Quickly realize what information is needed to solve a particular problem and how to obtain it. 0 0,0 3 5,8 10 19,2 21 40,4 18 34,6
Evaluate the validity of the information that has not been collected by him. 0 0,0 4 7,7 12 23,1 24 46,2 12 23,1
Learn quickly from experience. 0 0,0 0 0,0 4 7,7 22 42,3 26 50
Find and implement different solutions for different problems. 0 0,0 0 0,0 8 15,4 26 50 18 34,6
Perceive a situation from different perspectives. 0 0,0 4 7,7 17 32,7 19 36,5 12 23,1

With regard to the interpersonal skills dimension, 51.9% always express their feelings clearly and in the emotional skills dimension, 48.1% almost always face and resolve conflict situations and 42.3% almost always have the ability to take own decisions versus dependence on other people's opinions, likewise tolerance for ambiguity (Table 3).

Table 3.  Assessment scale on managerial skills in their interpersonal and emotional dimensions according to the perception of the Los Olivos Municipal Hospital staff. Lima 2019. 

Dimensions / indicators Rating scale
Never Rarely Sometimes Usually Always
n (%) n (%) n (%) n (%) n (%)
Interpersonal skills          
Select effective key subordinates. 1 1,9 9 17,3 14 26,9 20 38,5 8 15,4
Influence people over whom you do not have direct control. 4 7,7 13 25 17 32,7 12 23,1 6 11,5
Develop collaborative and teamwork work among his subordinates. 1 1,9 1 1,9 13 5,8 19 36,5 28 53,8
Communicate his thoughts and ideas clearly and persuasively. 0 0 0 0 7 13,5 24 46,2 21 40,4
DDevelop a climate of growth and development among your subordinates. 0 0 1 1,9 10 19,2 23 44,2 18 34,6
Diagnose complex interpersonal or group situations. 0 0 4 7,7 17 32,7 25 48,1 6 11,5
Express his feelings clearly. 0 0 1 1,9 5 9,6 19 36,5 27 51,9
Establish intergroup and cross-functional coordination processes. 0 0 2 3,8 12 23,1 25 48,1 13 25
Develop open and trusting relationships with his subordinates. 0 0 1 1,9 11 21,2 22 42,3 18 34,6
Listen to other people in an understanding way. 0 0 1 1,9 3 5,8 19 36,5 29 55,8
Emotional skills
Ability to make their own decisions v / s dependence on other people opinions. 1 1,9 3 5,8 12 23,1 22 42,3 14 26,9
Tolerance for ambiguity. 1 1,9 2 3,8 16 30,8 22 42,3 11 21,2
Follow a course of action, even if it makes him feel uncomfortable. 3 5,8 7 13,5 20 38,5 18 34,6 4 7,7
Taking risks and making decisions, even if it can have strong negative consequences. 3 5,8 7 13,5 18 34,6 20 38,5 4 7,7
Facing and resolving conflict situations (v / s avoiding or repressing them). 1 1,9 4 7,7 15 28,8 25 48,1 7 13,5
Make decisions with incomplete information in the face of a changing environment 12 23,1 13 25 16 30,8 10 19,2 1 1,9

Regarding managerial skills, the results showed 69% perceived an adequate level in the analytical skills and interpersonal skills dimensions. Meanwhile, 69% perceived a regular level in the emotional skills dimension and 58% in the motivations and values dimension (Figure 1). According to global evaluations, 55.8% perceived their bosses' managerial skills are adequate, 44.2% fair and none as inadequate. A correlation was established between service time and managerial skills (p = 0.021), according to Pearson's Chi-square test. The other sociodemographic variables did not show significant differences in relation to these skills. (Table 1).

Figure 1.  Assessments of managerial skills according to dimensions. 

DISCUSSION

This study results contribute to the empirical research on the management skills perceived by health personnel in a municipal hospital. Under theoretical foundations and empirical evidence, the managerial skills in health sector organizations role of has been supported. This study is according with the approaches of Griffin and Van Fleet9, stating that managers must demonstrate mastery of these skills; The combination of these in behavior, added to the effective execution of their basic managerial functions and activities, increase the success of the organization.

The perception of health personnel could be conditioned by subjective opinions and premeditated ideas about managerial skills. According to Otara10, in organizations, the perceptions of managers and employees shape the organizational climate and the work effectiveness, so managers must realize that staff have different perceptions, which makes it very difficult to achieve common objectives. In this sense, perception reflects the people's thinking and feelings, but it is not enough the bosses have the necessary skills for the position, but the staff perceive the same and recognize the skills required for that position11.

On the other hand, taking responsibility for management is a complex matter. It has long been viewed simply as an administrative activity of the medical profession; in this way, today it is important to promote and improve these often-underdeveloped management skills among health professionals, which is why, in addition to professional technical skills, they must possess management skills to optimize resources12.

Due to this reason, Aini13points out that the lack of trained managerial staff makes management systems ineffective. The hospital must be defined as an organization with a new leadership paradigm to foster the development of innovation and strive to integrate the diverse competencies of physicians and administrators in the management of patients and the health care system in general. The manager has to understand administration as a system or activity of planning, implementation, evaluation and improvement, carried out continuously to achieve a common goal and improve the quality of hospital services.

Therefore, the participants perceived in this study that their bosses have the ability to learn, the ability to continuously acquire knowledge and face reality, adapting to a rapidly changing environment. Along these lines, it should be noted that a study carried out in the United States14found that the leader was more respected if he had the humility to recognize and admit he is willing to learn from others. Another study carried out in Spain15refers the ability to learn of a manager is constituted in the value which helps to discover the importance of acquiring knowledge through the study and reflection of daily experiences and a deep vision of reality.

Certainly, listening is the ability to understand what is heard, and this perception encourages staff to express what they think about problems and their feelings and emotions, improving communication. For this reason, investigations carried out in other countries such as Rwanda10, the United States14, the Netherlands16and Cuba17, found in their studies that a leader must develop good listening skills. However, Torres2, found that only sometimes do managers listen empathically to the staff.

Another important skill is teamwork. In this regard, in Cuba17and Brazil18, results were shown that indicate that the most important skills specified by hospital managers are directly related to teamwork, which aims to obtain satisfactory results in the group they lead. The analysis suggests that teamwork is perceived by staff as the way to work together based on a relationship of trust to achieve common goals. Results have also been obtained in Chile19, which refers that a boss must influence the behavior of subordinates and possess leadership skills. Likewise, Hernández20highlights managers who put leadership into practice have the ability to promote and inspire their followers, influence their perspective and change it, if necessary. Therefore, it is a process by which an individual exerts influence on a group of individuals to achieve a common goal21.

It is appropriate to point out some limitations such as the size of the sample, the health care and administrative personnel with employment status were excluded service locator who constituted 70% of the population by provision of the hospital management. Another limitation was that research on managerial skills in the health sector is very scarce, which makes it difficult to compare the results obtained. A final limitation was the application of a subjective instrument, the information of which is based on the perception of the interviewees regarding their bosses and this could introduce bias in the results, due to the existence or not of retaliation at work or feelings of friendship, which was sought to control with an anonymous and voluntary survey.

CONCLUSION

Employees’ perception of management skills at Hospital Municipal Los Olivos have been considered adequate. The analytical and interpersonal skills dimensions presented better evaluations, while the regular evaluations correspond to the emotional skills and motivations and values dimensions. The workers' time of service is related to managerial skills.

REFERENCES

1. Pereda Pérez FJ. Análisis de las Habilidades Directivas. Estudio aplicado al sector público de la provincia de Córdoba (Tesis Doctoral). Córdoba: Facultad de Derecho y Ciencias Económicas y Empresariales, Universidad de Córdoba; 2016. 572 p. Disponible en: https://helvia.uco.es/xmlui/handle/10396/13398 [ Links ]

2. Torres T. Estrategias gerenciales administrativas para Centros Médicos Privados. Revista de Ciencias Sociales (RCS). 2013; 19(4): 650-62. [ Links ]

3. Whetten DA, Cameron KS. Desarrollo de habilidades directivas. 8va edición. México D.F.: Prentice Hall; 2011. 736 p. [ Links ]

4. Pereda-Pérez F, López-Guzmán-Guzmán T, González-Santa Cruz F. Las habilidades directivas como ventaja competitiva. El caso del sector público de la provincia de Córdoba (España). Intangible Capital. 2014; 10(3): 528-61. doi: dx.doi.org/10.3926/ic.511 [ Links ]

5. Pillay R. The skills gap in hospital management: a comparative analysis of hospital managers in the public and private sectors in South Africa. Health Serv Manage Res. 2010; 23(1): 30-6. doi: 10.1258/hsmr.2009.009015 [ Links ]

6. Rodríguez G, Peñarrieta M, Ajila D, Moreno K, Rodríguez G, Rodríguez S, et al. Habilidades gerenciales hospitalarias: Cómo desarrollar una gestión administrativa exitosa (Internet). Manta: Universidad Laica Eloy Alfaro de Manabí. 2018 (citado el 10 de junio del 2019). Disponible en: http://www.munayi.uleam.edu.ec/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/habilidades-gerenciales-hospitalarias-1.pdfLinks ]

7. García E. Los gerentes en la administración pública del Perú. América economía (Internet). 2013 (citado el 17 de junio del 2019). Disponible en: https://www.americaeconomia.com/analisis-opinion/los-gerentes-en-la-administracion-publica-del-peruLinks ]

8. Moreno Galarreta RR. Las habilidades gerenciales y el clima organizacional en el Hospital Nacional Hipólito Unanue El Agustino, 2017 (Tesis de maestría). Lima: Universidad César Vallejo; 2017. 154 p. Disponible en: http://repositorio.ucv.edu.pe/handle/20.500.12692/8864?locale-attribute=es [ Links ]

9. Griffin R, Van Fleet D. Habilidades Directivas, Evaluación y Desarrollo. México D.F.: Cengage Learning; 2015. 792 p. [ Links ]

10. Otara Alfred. Perception: A Guide for Managers and Leaders. Journal of Management and Strategy. 2011; 2(3): 21-4. doi: 10.5430/jms.v2n3p21 [ Links ]

11. Cetina T, Ortega I, Aguilar C. Habilidades directivas desde la percepción de los subordinados: Un enfoque relacional para el estudio del liderazgo. Psicoperspectivas. 2010; 9(1): 124-37. doi: 10.5027/psicoperspectivas-Vol9-Issue1-fulltext-94 [ Links ]

12. Fanelli S, Lanza G, Enna C, Zangrandi A. Managerial competences in public organisations: the healthcare professionals' perspective. BMC Health Serv Res. 2020; 20(303): 1-9. doi: 10.1186/s12913-020-05179-5 [ Links ]

13. Aini Q. Management Skill and Leadership: A Case Study from Hospital Managers of Charity Business in Health. J Soc Sci Res. 2018; 4(12): 478-82. doi: 10.32861/jssr.412.478.482 [ Links ]

14. Dine J, Kahn J, Abella B, Asch D, Shea J. Key Elements of Clinical Physician Leadership at an Academic Medical Center. J Grad Med Educ. 2011; 3: 31-6. doi: 10.4300/JGME-D-10-00017.1 [ Links ]

15. Pereda FJ, López-Guzmán T, Gonzáles F. La capacidad de aprender como habilidad directiva: una aplicación empírica en la administración local de la provincia de Córdoba, España. Investigación y Ciencia. 2015; 23(66): 28-36. [ Links ]

16. Van de Riet MCP, Berghout MA, Buljac-Samardzic M, van Exel J, Hilders CGJM. What makes an ideal hospital-based medical leader? Three views of healthcare professionals and managers: A case study. PLoS ONE. 2019; 14(6): e0218095. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0218095 [ Links ]

17. Jorna AR, Castañeda I, Véliz PL. Percepción de habilidades de liderazgo en hombres y mujeres para la dirección en salud en Cuba. Rev Cubana Salud Pública. 2016; 42(1): 70-9. [ Links ]

18. Grohmann MZ, Battistella LF, Baratto JS. Competencias del gestor hospitalario: estudio en un hospital público brasileño. Enferm Glob. 2012; 11(26): 191-208. doi: 10.4321/S1695-61412012000200013 [ Links ]

19. Quezada C, Illesca M, Cabezas M. Percepción del Liderazgo en las(os) Enfermeras(os) de un Hospital del Sur de Chile. Cienc Enferm. 2014; 20(2): 41-51. doi:10.4067/s0717-95532014000200005 [ Links ]

20. Hernández TJ, Duana D. Estudio diagnóstico de liderazgo transformacional en personal de enfermería que labora en hospitales públicos mexicanos. Revista Cimexus. 2018; 13(2): 89-109. [ Links ]

21. Sánchez M. Liderazgo en medicina: ¿debemos enseñarlo y evaluarlo? Investigación en Educación Médica. 2015; 4(14): 99-107. [ Links ]

Financing: Self-financed by the authors.

Received: February 05, 2021; Accepted: March 06, 2021

Correspondence: Irma Emperatriz Arrascue Lino. Address: Jr. Los Castaños 772 Urbanización Las Palmeras Distrito Los Olivos. Phone: 998587517 E-mail:emperatriz.arrascue@gmail.com

Authorship Contributions: The authors participated in the preparation and final review of this research work.

Interest conflict: The authors declare no conflict of interest.

Creative Commons License Este es un artículo publicado en acceso abierto bajo una licencia Creative Commons